Auto Insurance After an Accident: What Happens to Your Premium?

One of the biggest concerns of drivers is what happens to their car insurance after accident. In such a situation, the insurance company generally reassesses the policyholder's risk profile, which often leads to higher premium rates. However, the exact increase depends on factors like driver's fault, claim history, and your provider's policies. 

Continue reading this guide to understand how premiums change after an accident, which can help you make smarter financial decisions.

Why Does an Auto Insurance Rate Increase After an Accident?

The premium for car insurance after an accident generally increases as insurance companies see the claim as an indicator of higher future risk. In fact, most companies in the US calculate premiums depending on the possibilities for a larger payout in future payouts. Apart from that, the reason for increasing the premium follows: 

  • At-Fault Determination: If the driver is found responsible for the accident, they become a liability to the insurance company. However, in case the driver is not liable for the accident, insurance companies mostly do not increase the premium or raise it by a smaller margin. 

  • Claim Costs: The policyholders who make costlier claims for damages and injuries generally pay higher premiums. Since insurance companies cover these costs on behalf, they raise premiums to recoup these costs.

What are the Types of Accidents That Increase Insurance Premiums? 

To understand how an auto insurance rate increases after an accident, you must be aware of the two types of accidents: at-fault accidents and no-fault accidents. Here are the details. 

  1. At-fault Accidents

As the name suggests, an at-fault accident means the policyholder is liable for physical or property damage caused during an accident. Therefore, to cover the costs of these liabilities, most auto insurance companies in the US raise their premiums. 

However, some high-risk driver insurance offers coverages, such as personal injury protection and accident forgiveness, to prevent your premium from increasing after a car accident. 

This is why, to secure the correct car insurance, you should compare such coverage features and quotes of different insurance providers in the US through A-MAX Insurance.  

  1. No-fault Accidents

No-fault accidents mean that the policyholder is not responsible for the accident. Although it may seem unfair, sometimes accidents that are not your fault can still raise your rate depending on your state and policy terms. However, the hike rates are generally lower than the at-fault accidents. 

For instance, if you are a resident of Florida, insurance companies here can increase your premium by around 30% to 45%. 

How to File a Car Insurance Claim After an Accident?  

Now that you know what happens to the premium of your car insurance after an accident, it is essential to understand the steps to file a claim to ensure timely reimbursement and coverage during this stressful time. 

By navigating the A-MAX Insurance claim page, you can simply file for a car insurance claim. However, before making the claim, you must also take certain steps as discussed below. 

Step 1: Ensure Safety and Call Police

Before initiating the claim for auto insurance after an accident, ensure you move to a safe area and get proper medical attention in case you or any third party has suffered any injuries. Moreover, if the accident resulted in any huge vehicle damage or fatalities, it is essential to file an Incident Report with the local police. 

Step 2: Document the Scene

You must collect the photos of the damaged vehicles, the accident scene, the road conditions, and medical documents as proof to submit during claims. In fact, these documents will ultimately determine the legitimacy of your car insurance claim. Additionally, it will also decide how much of a hike there will be in your premium rates. 

Step 3: Notify Your Insurance Provider

After ensuring proper medical attention to the injured and notifying the police, you must immediately contact A-MAX Insurance. Remember, unnecessary delays can complicate the claim, as many insurers have specific time limits. For any guidance, you can call 800-979-2629 to speak to our customer service representative. 

Step 4: File For a Claim via the Website of A-MAX Insurance 

Once you have prepared all the documents, you can file for an auto insurance claim via the website of A-MAX Insurance. You have to simply look for your insurance company on our website, or click on the box containing the first letters of your policy. 

After clicking on the name, you will be redirected to your provider's website, from where you can file the claim by filling out the claim form. 

Average Hike in Car Insurance Rates After an Accident 

In the US, car insurance rates for full coverage increase around 20% to 40% after an at-fault accident. In fact, according to the U.S. News & World Report, a single at-fault accident can annually increase rates by more than $1,300. However, the rate can vary significantly by state, claim history, and insurer. 

If you have an accident on your record, contact A-MAX Insurance now to get quotes for at-fault accident insurance. Moreover, we will help you to purchase affordable car insurance after an accident by comparing different quotes and coverage features. 

What Factors Affect the Auto Insurance Cost After the Accident? 

The premium of your car insurance after an accident generally depends on factors such as the severity of the accident, location, driving history, and company-specific policy. Let's discover these factors in detail. 

  1. Accident Severity and Cost

Any minor accidents generally result in a smaller premium increase compared to a major accident, which causes significant property damage or bodily injury claims. 

  1. Driving Record History

If you have a clean record with no accidents or other violations, your premiums will not change. However, if you have a history of traffic violations or accident records, including speeding tickets or Driving Under Influence (DUI), your premiums will likely increase more. 

  1. Location

Your residency significantly affects your premium. Since policyholders living in urban areas with higher traffic and accident frequency result in higher costs as compared to rural areas. 

Moreover, the rules can also vary across some states. For instance, in California, it is illegal for insurance companies to raise rates after a car accident if the policyholder is not at fault. 

  1. Vehicle Type

Most insurers consider the year, make and model of your car, features and repair costs to raise the premium of car insurance after an accident. This is because expensive or high-performance vehicles like Rolls-Royce have costlier parts, which often lead to higher repair costs. 

  1. Insurance Company Policy

Higher coverage limits and lower deductibles can increase your car insurance premium after an accident. Additionally, each insurance company has its own policies for raising and calculating premiums. 

While some high-risk driver insurance offers accident forgiveness coverage for your first-time offenders, others could raise your rates regardless of your frequency or part in the accident.

How Can I Lower My Auto Insurance Premiums After an Accident? 

As you now know, how much will auto insurance increase after an accident and the factors that influence its premium rates, discover the tips to lower these rates while ensuring comprehensive protection. 

  • Ensure having the Accident Forgiveness Feature: With the accident forgiveness insurance coverage, your premium will not rise during your first at-fault accident. However, since policy features can vary across insurers, always read the policy terms carefully to stay covered under this benefit. 

  • Bundle Policies: By purchasing multiple policies from one insurer, you can significantly reduce your monthly premium with around 14% discount, according to Forbes. Therefore, try to combine your auto insurance with a home or health insurance. 

  • Shop Around: Premium increases vary significantly by company after an accident. Therefore, if you think your current insurance provider is charging a higher premium, you can switch to a different provider. 

  • Remove Optional Coverage: If your car is older or has a low market value, you can drop the comprehensive or collision coverage to save on premiums.

  • Improve Credit Score: Try to maintain a good credit score, as in many U.S states, insurers use a credit-based insurance score to help determine rates. This is because your credit behavior directly determines your claim risk.

Conclusion 

Car insurance after accident often becomes more expensive due to increased risk and claim history. In fact, depending on factors such as fault, past claims, and insurer policy terms, insurers often determine the premium hike. 

This is why, to control your costs effectively, keep a safe driving habit, compare quotes, and adjust your insurance deductibles before purchasing an auto insurance policy. 

If you need reliable guidance to purchase affordable car insurance after an accident, connect with A-MAX Insurance today and secure better protection with complete peace of mind.

Frequently Asked Questions

Car insurance rates remain increased for 3 to 5 years following an at-fault accident as insurers view you as a higher-risk driver during this period.

Yes, you can switch auto insurance after an accident. However, you may not avoid premium hikes as the new insurer will also consider you a high-risk driver based on your previous accident records. 

Yes, most auto insurance companies in the US cover third-party liability if the policyholder is at fault in an accident. With liability coverage, they can pay for the other party’s medical bills and vehicle repairs up to their policy limits.

If your auto insurance policy includes rental reimbursement coverage, you can file a claim after an accident. However, since this coverage is not an in-built feature in a standard liability-only policy, you have to purchase it as an optional coverage. 

There is no legal limit on the number of auto insurance claims you can file in a year in the US. Yet, insurers have the right to cancel your policy after two or more at-fault accidents within a single policy period. 

Yes, even if you are a first-time offender, your auto-insurance premium will rise after a fault accident or serious traffic violation, as insurers view it as an increased risk. But you can avoid it with the accident forgiveness coverage.

Yes, a comprehensive claim often increases your premium rate. However, as the non-collision events like car theft or weather damage are not under your control, the premium hikes are generally less than a smaller amount than at-fault collision claims.

Yes, your car insurance claim can be rejected after an accident due to various reasons. For instance, if you do not have proper evidence of the accident or the accident was caused by any illegal activity, such as driving under the influence of alcohol, it may be difficult to obtain compensation.

To file a claim for your car insurance after accident, you will need certain essential documents, including the official police report, medical records, photographs of the scene, and insurance information.

If your insurance claim is rejected after an accident, you should immediately request a formal letter of denial to thoroughly review the policy’s coverage, exclusions, and appeal procedures. In case you find the reason for your denial is wrong, gather evidence to make a reapplication.

Published: March 30, 2026

Let's Start Saving

meet us

Drop by One of Our
Convenient Locations

and chat with a friendly agent!

Find a Location Near You!
Call Us Text Us Message Visit